|
"I can resist everything," Oscar Wilde once quipped, "except temptation." The same apparently goes for some scientists.
A cellular biologist at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in Berkeley, Calif., was found last spring to have faked his data in two studies published in 1992 that linked
high-voltage power lines to cancer. Robert P. Liburdy claimed to have found a connection between the electromagnetic fields around power lines and certain cellular changes in the body.
Those findings, long suspected by one segment of scientists but never before confirmed, contributed to public fear about cancer.After a whistle-blower at the laboratory challenged Liburdy's
results, an internal investigation began. In July 1995, the investigators concluded that Liburdy had indeed falsified information, and they referred the case to the federal Office of
Research Integrity (ORI). That agency ruled last July that Liburdy had "engaged in scientific misconduct in biomedical research by intentionally falsifying and fabricating data and claims." In
addition, ORI said that "the evidence demonstrates Liburdy knew his data manipulations were significant to the conclusions of the paper." In a letter to the journal Science
, however, Liburdy denied doing anything wrong. "My scientific conclusions stand as published," he wrote. "I admit no scientific wrongdoing." He added that he
couldn't afford an expensive legal battle and decided to settle without admitting liability. Last March, he resigned from his 15-year position at the Lawrence Berkeley lab after losing $3.3 million in
federal grants for his research, which ORI officials said he won based on the misrepresentations made in his studies. Such cases of scientific malfeasance are rare, though. Since it was established in 1992, ORI has
dealt with more than 1,000 allegations of fabrication and falsification of data and plagiarism among tens of thousands of research projects amounting to more than $8 billion a year. Of the complaints
received, about 20% required a formal inquiry and misconduct was found in just over 100 cases. There is honor among scientists after all. |